close
close

first Drop

Com TW NOw News 2024

Michigan State gets another reality check against Oregon. But that’s okay
news

Michigan State gets another reality check against Oregon. But that’s okay

play

EUGENE, Ore. – Free Press sportswriter Rainer Sabin answers three questions after No. 6 Oregon defeated Michigan State 31-10 on Friday.

Could the Spartans avoid shooting themselves in the foot?

Aidan Chiles looked grumpy earlier this week as he complained about the three red zone opportunities Michigan State squandered during a 31-point loss to Ohio State last Saturday.

“I can’t leave a drive with no points,” the second-year quarterback said.

But the Spartans had developed a nasty habit of doing just that. Before Friday, the Spartans had scored inside the 20-yard line on just 66.7% of their chances, one of the lowest marks in the entire Football Bowl Subdivision.

Flash forward to MSU’s opening possession against Oregon and there were the Spartans on the cusp of the Ducks’ end zone, on the 2-yard line. Chiles had just completed a 44-yard pass to Nick Marsh after head coach Jonathan Smith made the brave call to go for it on fourth down, just past midfield. A raucous Autzen Stadium had suddenly become quiet. Then, with the next click, it got loud again. As Chiles charged toward the goal line at a goalkeeper, the ball was dislodged from his arms. It flowed over the goal line and Oregon’s Jordan Burch smothered it for a touchback. So a chance for an early lead went up in smoke. MSUs 14e turnovers, and Chiles’ 11e of the season set the stage for another failure in the red zone for a team that just can’t seem to get out of the way.

Has Jonathan Smith learned in one week just how big the gap is between MSU and the Big Ten’s elite?

GAME SUMMARY: Michigan State vs. Football Score Oregon Today: Game Recap, Week 6 Game Highlights

Although Oregon’s roots are in the Pac-12, these Ducks are cast in a Big Ten mold. Dan Lanning’s team plays a physical brand of football, and it was on full display Friday. Against MSU, Oregon controlled the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball. The Ducks’ ground attack chewed through MSU’s front, while their running backs sprinted through gaping holes into the second and third levels of the Spartans’ defense.

En route to a 21-0 halftime lead, Oregon gained 192 rushing yards and their leading ball carrier, Jordan James, scored 151. As James ran through MSU, the Spartans’ own running game could not gain traction. Nate Carter and Kay’Ron Lynch-Adams were repeatedly confronted by Oregon’s ferocious frontline defenders in the backfield after MSU’s line of blockers folded from one to the other like a house of cards. It was the second week in a row that MSU’s biggest weakness was exposed by a superior opponent.

Last Saturday, Ohio State outplayed MSU’s offensive line at the point of attack and stifled the Spartans’ ground game. MSU rushed for just 47 yards on 25 attempts when Carter and Lynch-Adams came up short. They were stifled again on Friday while being held to a total of 43 yards on 14 carries. Poor ground production, which was a recurring problem during last season’s dreadful 4-8 slog, is one reason why Jonathan Smith said after last week’s loss that MSU is still “a long way” from matching Ohio State . By destroying MSU in the trenches, Oregon reminded the Spartans how far the distance is between them and the Big Ten’s elite. It starts at the front and MSU isn’t good enough there to compete against the best teams in the conference.

Are Michigan State’s recent struggles surprising?

Thanks to what he accomplished during an impressive six-year stint in Corvallis at Oregon State, Jonathan Smith had a well-deserved reputation as a program builder. But he was never seen as a miracle worker. The Beavers gradually improved their record over time, increasing their win total from two to five to seven to ten wins in his first four full seasons. When he arrived at MSU last November, Smith took on another major renovation project. Last season he overhauled the squad and welcomed 61 new players. He also lost some valuable pieces to the transfer portal, including one — defensive tackle Derrick Harmon — who made his presence felt Friday when he sacked Chiles for an 11-yard loss in the first quarter.

The reality was that MSU was always going to be a work in progress this year. And six games into Smith’s young regime, the Spartans are nowhere near a finished product. Instead, they’re a team that looks pretty rough. The shortcomings we’ve seen on both sides of the ball in the first half of the season are proof of that. On offense, MSU was inefficient and turnover-prone. On defense, the Spartans don’t have enough depth, as evidenced by Oregon and Ohio State. None of this is surprising. The Spartans are the team most expected to lead the program at this stage of Smith’s first season.